Geostatistical analysis of density indices in traditionally managed oak forests

Abbasi, L, Shakeri, Z, Shabanian, N & Moreno, G 2017, Branch and leaf biomass of Lebanon oak (Quercus libani Oliv.) and gall oak (Q. infectoria Oliv.) trees in different years after pollarding. Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 25: 46-35, [In Persian].

Achard, F, Mollicone, D, Stibig, HJ, Aksenov, D, Laestadius, L, Li, Z, Popatov, P & Yaroshenko, A 2006, Areas of rapid forest-cover change in boreal eurasia. Forest Ecology and Management, 237: 322-334.

Ahadi, Z, Alavi, J & Hoseini, M, 2017, Beech forest site productivity mapping using ordinary kriging and IDW (Case study: Research forest of Tarbiat Modares University). Forest and Wood Products, 70: 93-102, [In Persian].

Ahmed, C, Mohammed, A & Tahir, A 2020, Geostatistics of strength, modeling and GIS mapping of soil properties for residential purpose for Sulaimani City soils, Kurdistan Region, Iraq. Modeling Earth Systems and Environment, 6: 879-893.

Akhavan, R & Kleinn, C 2009, On the potential of kriging for estimation and mapping of forest plantation stock (case study: Beneshki plantation). Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 17: 318-303, [In Persian].

Akhavan, R, ZahediAmiri, G & Zobeiri, M 2010, Spatial variability of forest growing stock using geostatistics in the Caspian region of Iran. Caspian Journal of Environmental Sciences, 8: 43-53.

Akhavan, R & Kia-Daliri, H 2010, Spatial variability and estimation of tree attributes in a plantation forest in the Caspian region of Iran using geostatistical analysis. Caspian Journal of Environmental Sciences, 8: 163-172.

Akhavan, R, Kia-Daliri, H & Etemad, V 2015, Geostatistically estimation and mapping of forest stock in a natural unmanaged forest in the Caspian region of Iran. Caspian Journal of Environmental Sciences, 13: 61-76.

Akhavan, R, Khanhasani, M & Khodakarami, Y 2018, Spatial patterns and inter-specific competition of three oak species in the Baneh forests of western Iran. Forest and Wood Products, 71: 149-159, [In Persian].

Alemu, B, Animut, G & Tolera, A 2013, Millettia ferruginea: an endemic legume tree as forage for ruminants in southern and northwestern Ethiopia. Livestock Research for Rural Development, 25.

Allard, D, Senoussi, R & Porcu, E 2016, Anisotropy models for spatial data. Mathematical Geosciences, 48: 305-328.

Appel, E, Barbosa, IC, Seidel, EJ & Oliveira, MSD 2018, Spatial dependence index for cubic, pentaspherical and wave semivariogram models. Boletim de Ciências Geodésicas, 24: 142-151.

Arétouyap, Z, Nouck, NP, Nouayou, R, Méli’i, JL, KemgangGhomsi, FE, PiepiToko, AD & Asfahani, J 2015, Influence of the variogram model on an interpolative survey using kriging technique. Journal of Earth Science & Climatic Change, 6: 316-316.

Azawi, H & Saleh, MS 2021, Review of the kriging technique applications to groundwater quality. Journal of Engineering, 27: 23-32.

Babcock, C, Finley, AO, Andersen, HE, Pattison, R, Cook, BD, Morton, DC, Alonzo, M, Nelson, R, Gregoire, T, Ene, L & Gobakken, T 2018, Geostatistical estimation of forest biomass in interior Alaska combining Landsat-derived tree cover, sampled airborne lidar and field observations. Remote Sensing of Environment, 212: 212-230.

Bargaoui, ZK & Chebbi, A 2009, Comparison of two kriging interpolation methods applied to spatiotemporal rainfall. Journal of Hydrology, 365: 56-73.

Berhe, DH & Tanga, AA 2013, Nutritional evaluation of Ficus thonningii Blume leaves as ruminant livestock feed in the Ahferom district of Tigray, Ethiopia. African Journal of Range & Forage Science, 30: 149-154.

Bhunia, GS, Keshavarzi, A, Shit, PK, Omran, ESE & Bagherzadeh, A 2018, Evaluation of groundwater quality and its suitability for drinking and irrigation using GIS and geostatistics techniques in semiarid region of Neyshabur, Iran. Applied Water Science, 8: 1-16.

Bivand, R 2008, Applied spatial data analysis with R. Springer, New York, USA, 374 p.

Bivand, RS 2009, Exploratory spatial data analysis. In: Handbook of Applied Spatial Analysis: Software Tools, Methods and Applications. Springer, Berlin, Germany, pp. 219-254.

Bonan, GB 2008, Forests and climate change: forcings, feedbacks, and the climate benefits of forests. Science, 320: 1444-1449.

Borel, R & Romero, F 1991, On-farm research in a silvopastoral project: a case study. Agroforestry Systems, 15: 245-257.

Buongiorno, J, Halvorsen, EA, Bollandsås, OM, Gobakken, T & Hofstad, O 2012, Optimizing management regimes for carbon storage and other benefits in uneven-aged stands dominated by Norway spruce, with a derivation of the economic supply of carbon storage. Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research, 27: 460-473.

Burner, DM, Pote, DH & Ares, A 2005, Management effects on biomass and foliar nutritive value of Robinia pseudoacacia and Gleditsia triacanthos f. inermis in Arkansas, USA. Agroforestry Systems, 65: 207-214.

Cambardella, CA, Moorman, TB, Novak, JM, Parkin, TB, Karlen, DL, Turco, RF.& Konopka, AE 1994, Field-scale variability of soil properties in central Iowa soils. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 58: 1501-1511.

Chiles, JP & Delfiner, P 2012, Geostatistics: modeling spatial uncertainty. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, USA, 713 p.

Dalchiavon, FC, dePassoseCarvalho, M, Andreotti, M & Montanari, R 2012, Spatial variability of the fertility attributes of Dystropheric Red Latosol under a no-tillage system. Revista Ciência Agronômica, 43: 453.

Diodato, N 2005, Geostatistical uncertainty modelling for the environmental hazard assessment during single erosive rainstorm events. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 105: 25-42.

Fattahi, M 1994, Study of western Iranian oak forests and their main degradation causes. Research Institute of Forest and Rangeland, Tehran, Iran, 210 p., [In Persian].

Freeman, EA & Moisen, GG 2007, Evaluating kriging as a tool to improve moderate resolution maps of forest biomass. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 128: 395-410.

Franzel, S, Carsan, S, Lukuyu, B, Sinja, J & Wambugu, C 2014, Fodder trees for improving livestock productivity and smallholder livelihoods in Africa. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 6: 98-103.

Ganawa, ESM, Soom, MAM, Musa, MH, Shariff, AM & Wayayok, A 2003, Spatial variability of total nitrogen and available phosphorus of large rice field in Sawah Sempadan Malaysia. Science Asia, 29: 7-12.

Gazolla-Neto, A, Fernandes, MC, Vergara, RDO, Gadotti, GI & Villela, FA 2016, Spatial distribution of the chemical properties of the soil and of soybean yield in the field. Revista Ciência Agronômica, 47: 325-333.

Geta, T, Nigatu, L & Animut, G 2014, Evaluation of potential yield and chemical composition of selected indigenous multi-purpose fodder trees in three districts of Wolayta Zone, Southern Ethiopia. World Applied Sciences Journal, 31: 399-405.

Ghahramany, L, Shakeri, Z, Ghalavand, E & Ghazanfari, H 2017, Does diameter increment of Lebanon oak trees (Quercus libani Oliv.) affected by pollarding in Northern Zagros, Iran? Agroforestry Systems, 91: 741-748.

Ghahramany, L, Ghazanfari, H, Fatehi, P & Valipour, A 2018, Structure of pollarded oak forest in relation to aspect in Northern Zagros, Iran. Agroforestry Systems, 92: 1567-1577, [In Persian].

Ghazanfari, H, Namiranian, M, Sobhani, H & Mohajer, RM 2004, Traditional forest management and its application to encourage public participation for sustainable forest management in the northern Zagros Mountains of Kurdistan Province, Iran. Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research, 19: 65-71.

Goergen, LCDG, Narvaes, IDS, Miquelutti, DJ, Chang, SX & Silva, EA 2020, Geostatistical behavior of dendrometric variables of Eucalyptus benthamii for forest management purpose. Scientia Forestalis, 48: 1-15.

GoldenSoftware 2025, Anisotropy, Golden Software Documentation. Available online: https://surferhelp. goldensoftware.com/griddata/Anisotropy.htm (accessed January 2, 2025).

Günlü, A, Bulut, S, Keleş, S & Ercanlı, İ 2020, Evaluating different spatial interpolation methods and modeling techniques for estimating spatial forest site index in pure beech forests: a case study from Turkey. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 192: 1-11.

Gunnarsson, F, Holm, S, Holmgren, P & Thuresson, T 1998, On the potential of kriging for forest management planning. Scandinavian Journal of Forest Research, 13: 237-245.

Harris, TM 2017, Exploratory spatial data analysis: tight coupling data and space, spatial data mining, and hypothesis generation. In: Regional Research Frontiers, Vol. 2: Methodological Advances, Regional Systems Modeling and Open Sciences. Springer, Cham, Switzerland, pp. 181-191.

Hawchar, L, ElSoueidy, CP & Schoefs, F 2018, Global kriging surrogate modeling for general time-variant reliability-based design optimization problems. Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization, 58: 955-968.

Hemingway, H & Opalach, D 2024, Integrating lidar canopy height models with satellite-assisted inventory methods: a comparison of inventory estimates. Forest Science, 70: 2-13.

Hengl, T, Heuvelink, GB & Rossiter, DG 2007, About regression-kriging: from equations to case studies. Computers & Geosciences, 33: 1301-1315.

Heuvelink, GB 1998, Error propagation in environmental modelling with GIS. CRC Press, Boca Raton, USA, 150 p.

Humagain, K, Portillo-Quintero, C, Cox, RD & CainIII, JW 2017, Mapping tree density in forests of the southwestern USA using Landsat 8 data. Forests, 8: 287.

Hernandez, J & Emery, X 2009, A geostatistical approach to optimize sampling designs for local forest inventories. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 39: 1465-1474.

Huang, YF, Ding, Y, Zang, RG, Li, XC, Zou, ZC & Han, WT 2012, Spatial pattern of trees in tropical lowland rain forest in Bawangling of Hainan Island, China. Chinese Journal of Plant Ecology, 36: 269-280.

Husch, B, Beers, TW & Kershaw JA 2002, Forest mensuration. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, USA, 456 p.

Hurteau, MD., 2021, The role of forests in the carbon cycle and in climate change. In: Climate Change. Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands, pp. 561-579.

Izadi, S & Sohrabi, H 2022, Estimating the spatial distribution of above-ground carbon of Zagros forests using regression kriging, geographically weighted regression kriging and Landsat 8 imagery. Journal of Geomatics Science and Technology, 9: 113-124. [In Persian].

Jazirei, MH. & Ebrahimi Rostaghi, M 2003, Silviculture in Zagros forest. Tehran University Press, Tehran, Iran, 400 p. [In Persian].

John, K, Afu, SM, Isong, IA, Aki, EE, Kebonye, NM, Ayito, EO, Chapman, PA, Eyong, MO & Penížek, V 2021, Mapping soil properties with soil-environmental covariates using geostatistics and multivariate statistics. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 18: 1-16.

Kalbi, S, Fallah, A, Shataee, S, Yousefpour, R & Bettinger, P 2017, Mapping the spatial distribution of forest growth characteristics using different geostatistical methods (case study: District No. 3, Sangdeh-Sari). Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 25: 196-208, [In Persian].

Karami, O, Fallah, A, Shataei, SH & Latifi, H 2018, Assessment of geostatistical and interpolation methods for mapping forest dieback intensity in Zagros forests. Caspian Journal of Environmental Sciences, 16: 71-84.

Khedri, L, Ghahramany, L, Ghazanfari, H & Pulido, F 2017, A quantitative study of pollarding process in silvopastoral systems of Northern Zagros, Iran. Forest Systems, 26: e018.

Khosravi, S, Namiranian, M, Ghazanfari, H & Shirvani, A 2012, Estimation of leaf area index and assessment of its allometric equations in oak forests: Northern Zagros, Iran. Journal of Forest Science, 58: 116-122.

Klobučar, D. & Pernar, R 2012, Geostatistical approach to spatial analysis of forest damage. Periodicum Biologorum, 114: 103-110.

Li, J. & Heap, AD 2014, Spatial interpolation methods applied in the environmental sciences: a review. Environmental Modelling & Software, 53: 173-189.

Luo, P, Song, Y, Li, W & Meng, L 2024, Pervasive impact of spatial dependence on predictability. arXiv Preprint arXiv:2408.14722.

Ma, C 2007, Why is isotropy so prevalent in spatial statistics? Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 135: 865-871.

Marvi Mohajer, MR 2005, Silviculture. Tehran University Press, Tehran, Iran, 500 p., [In Persian].

Maselli, F & Chiesi, M 2006, Evaluation of statistical methods to estimate forest volume in a Mediterranean region. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 44: 2239-2250.

Myers, JC 1997, Geostatistical error management: quantifying uncertainty for environmental sampling and mapping. John Wiley & Sons, New York, USA, 350 p.

Meyer, S, Blaschek, M, Duttmann, R & Ludwig, R 2016, Improved hydrological model parametrization for climate change impact assessment under data scarcity—the potential of field monitoring techniques and geostatistics. Science of the Total Environment, 543: 906-923.

Miao, C & Wang, Y 2024, Interpolation of non-stationary geo-data using kriging with sparse representation of covariance function. Computers and Geotechnics, 169: 106183.

Mitas, L & Mitasova, H 1999, Spatial interpolation. In: Geographical Information Systems: Principles, Techniques, Management and Applications, Vol. 1. Wiley, New York, USA, pp. 481-492.

Montes, F, Hernández, MJ & Cañellas, I 2005, A geostatistical approach to cork production sampling estimation in Quercus suber forests. Canadian Journal of Forest Research, 35: 2787-2796.

Mulder, VL, De Bruin, S, Weyermann, J, Kokaly, RF & Schaepman, ME 2013, Characterizing regional soil mineral composition using spectroscopy and geostatistics. Remote Sensing of Environment, 139: 415-429.

Munyati, C. & Sinthumule, NI 2021, Comparative suitability of ordinary kriging and inverse distance weighted interpolation for indicating intactness gradients on threatened savannah woodland and forest stands. Environmental and Sustainability Indicators, 12: 100151.

Negreiros, J, Painho, M, Aguilar, F & Aguilar, M 2010, Geographical information systems principles of ordinary kriging interpolator. Journal of Applied Sciences, 10: 852-867.

Nanos, N, Calama, R, Montero, G & Gil, L 2004, Geostatistical prediction of height/diameter models. Forest Ecology and Management, 195: 221-235.

Newton, PF 2012, A decision-support system for forest density management within upland black spruce stand-types. Environmental Modelling & Software, 35: 171-187.

Oliver, MA & Webster, R 1990, Kriging: a method of interpolation for geographical information systems. International Journal of Geographical Information System, 4: 313-332.

Oliver, MA, Webster, R & McGrath, SP 1996, Disjunctive kriging for environmental management. Environmetrics, 7: 333-357.

Olthoff, AE, Gómez, C, Alday, JG & Martínez-Ruiz, C 2018, Mapping forest vegetation patterns in an Atlantic–Mediterranean transitional area by integration of ordination and geostatistical techniques. Journal of Plant Ecology, 11: 114-122.

Pascual, C, Mauro, F, Hernando, A & Martín-Fernández, S 2013, Inventory techniques in participatory forest management. Quantitative techniques in participatory forest management. CRC Press, Boca Ratón, pp. 53-134.

Peri, PL, Bahamonde, HA, Lencinas, MV, Gargaglione, V, Soler, R, Ormaechea, S & Pastur, GM 2016, A review of silvopastoral systems in native forests of Nothofagus antarctica in southern Patagonia, Argentina. Agroforestry Systems, 90: 933-960.

Pelissari, AL, Roveda, M, Caldeira, SF, Sanquetta, CR, Corte, APD & Rodrigues, CK 2017, Geostatistical modeling of timber volume spatial variability for Tectona grandis LF precision forestry. Cerne, 23: 115-122.

Pinkard, EA, Battaglia, M, Beadle, CL & Sands, PJ 1999, Modeling the effect of physiological responses to green pruning on net biomass production of Eucalyptus nitens. Tree Physiology, 19: 1-12.

Raimundo, MR, Scolforo, HF, de Mello, JM, Scolforo, JRS, McTague, JP & dos Reis, AA 2017, Geostatistics applied to growth estimates in continuous forest inventories. Forest Science, 63: 29-38.

Raju, NJ 2016, Geostatistical and geospatial approaches for the characterization of natural resources in the environment. Cham: Springer, 969 p.

Ranjbar, A, Ghahramani, L & Pourhashemi, M 2012, Impact assessment of pollarding on biometrical indices of Lebanon oak (Quercus libani Oliv.) in Belake Forests, Baneh. Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 20: 578-594 (In Persian).

Ray, D, Seymour, R, Fraver, S, Berrill, JP, Kenefic, L, Rogers, N & Weiskittel, A 2023, Relative density as a standardizing metric for the development of size-density management charts. Journal of Forestry, 121: 443-456.

Rawat, YS & Everson, CS 2013, Availability and use of willow species in representative cold desert areas of northwestern himalaya, India. Journal of Mountain Science, 10: 472-481.

Rehman, S, Sajjad, H, Masroor, M, Rahaman, MH, Roshani, Ahmed, R & Sahana, M 2022, Assessment of evidence-based climate variability in Bhagirathi sub-basin of India: a geostatistical analysis. Acta Geophysica, 70: 445-463.

Reza, SK, Nayak, DC, Mukhopadhyay, S, Chattopadhyay, T & Singh, SK 2017, Characterizing spatial variability of soil properties in alluvial soils of India using geostatistics and geographical information system. Archives of Agronomy and Soil Science, 63: 1489-1498.

Rezaei, E, Akhavan, R, Soosani, J & Pourhashemi, M 2014, Efficiency of kriging for estimation and mapping of crown cover and density of Zagros Oak forests (Case study: Dadabad Region, Khorramabad). Forest and Wood Products, 67: 359-370, [In Persian].

Rojimol, J, Phanindra, KBVN & Umashankar, B 2021, Application of ordinary kriging for in situ site characterization. In Proceedings of the Indian Geotechnical Conference 2019: IGC-2019 Volume V, Springer Singapore, pp. 551-563.

Rostami Jalilian, A, Ghahramany, L, Ghazanfari, H & Shakeri, Z 2016, Response of Gall oak (Quercus infectoria Oliv.) to pollarding in northern Zagros. Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 24: 633-645, [In Persian].Rozas, V, Zas, R & Solla, A 2009, Spatial structure of deciduous forest stands with contrasting human influence in northwest Spain. European Journal of Forest Research, 128: 273-285.

Safari, A, Shabanian, N, Heidari, RH, Erfanifard, SY & Pourreza, M 2010, Spatial pattern of Manna oak trees (Quercus brantii Lindl.) in Bayangan forests of Kermanshah. Iranian Journal of Forest and Poplar Research, 18(4):608-596, [In Persian].

Sales, MH, SouzaJr, CM, Kyriakidis, PC, Roberts, DA & Vidal, E 2007, Improving spatial distribution estimation of forest biomass with geostatistics: A case study for Rondônia, Brazil. Ecological Modelling, 205(1-2): 221-230.

Schiappapietra, E & Douglas, J 2020, Modelling the spatial correlation of earthquake ground motion: Insights from the literature, data from the 2016–2017 Central Italy earthquake sequence and ground-motion simulations. Earth-Science Reviews, 203:103139.

Scott, CT & Gove, JH 2002, Forest inventory. Encyclopedia of Environmetrics, 2:814-820.

Selmy, S., AbdEl-Aziz, S., El-Desoky, A. & El-Sayed, M 2022, Characterizing, predicting, and mapping of soil spatial variability in Gharb El-Mawhoub area of Dakhla Oasis using geostatistics and GIS approaches. Journal of the Saudi Society of Agricultural Sciences, 21(6): 383-396.

Shahabedini, S, Ghahramany, L, Pulido, F, Khosravi, S & Moreno, G 2018, Estimating leaf biomass of pollarded Lebanon oak in open silvopastoral systems using allometric equations. Trees, 32: 99-108.

She, GH, Lin, GZ, Wen, XR, Lin, SM & Ye, J S2007, Improvement of forest inventory method for management plan and stand growth estimation on horizontal point sample. Journal of Nanjing Forestry University, 50(05): 11.

Silveira, EM, Reis, AA, Terra, MC, Withey, KD, Mello, JM, Acerbi-Junior, FW & FerrazFilho, AC 2019, Spatial distribution of wood volume in Brazilian savannas. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências, 91: e20180666.

Siviero, E, Chautru, E & Clémençon, S 2024, A statistical learning view of simple Kriging. TEST, 33(1):271-296.

Sukkuea, A & Heednacram, A 2022, Prediction on spatial elevation using improved kriging algorithms: An application in environmental management. Expert Systems with Applications, 207: 117971.

Svidzinska, D 2019, The application of directional univariate structure functions analysis for studying the spatial anisotropy of environmental variables. Ekológia (Bratislava), 38(2): 140-153.

Thonon, I. & CacheiroPose, M 2001, Geostatistical interpolation of topographical field data in order to obtain a DEM of a small forest catchment in Northwest Spain. Cadernos do Laboratorio Xeolóxico de Laxe, 26: 179-190.

Tiryana, T 2005, Predicting spatial distribution of stand volume using geostatistics. Jurnal Manajemen Hutan Tropika, 11(2): 15-27.

Vafaei, S, Maleknia, R, Naghavi, H & Fathizadeh, O 2022, Estimation of forest canopy using remote sensing and geostatistics (case study: Marivan Baghan Forests). J Environ Sci Technol, 24: 71-82, [In Persian].

Valipour, A, Plieninger, T, Shakeri, Z, Ghazanfari, H, Namiranian, M & Lexer, MJ 2014, Traditional silvopastoral management and its effects on forest stand structure in northern Zagros, Iran. Forest Ecology and Management, 327: 221-230.

Villegas, P, Cavagna, A, Cencini, M, Fort, H & Grigera, TS2021, Joint assessment of density correlations and fluctuations for analysing spatial tree patterns. Royal Society Open Science, 8(1):202200.

Verbovšek, T 2024, Analysis of Karst surface anisotropy using directional semivariograms, Slovenia. Pure and Applied Geophysics, 181(1): 233-245.

Wackernagel, H 1996, Multivariate geostatistics: An introduction with applications. In International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences and Geomechanics Abstracts, 8(33): 363A.

WalterIII, JF, Christman, MC, Hoenig, JM & Mann, R 2007, Combining data from multiple years or areas to improve variogram estimation. Environmetrics: The Official Journal of the International Environmetrics Society, 18(6): 583-598.

Webster, R & Oliver, MA 2007, Geostatistics for environmental scientists. John Wiley & Sons.

Woodall, CW, D’Amato, AW, Bradford, JB & Finley, AO 2012, Stand density index as a tool to assess the maximization of forest carbon and biomass. In: McWilliams, Will; Roesch, Francis A. eds., Monitoring Across Borders: 2010 Joint Meeting of the Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) Symposium and the Southern Mensurationists, e-Gen. Tech. Rep. SRS-157. Asheville, NC: US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Southern Research Station, pp. 293-296.

Wu, Z, Yao, F, Zhang, J & Liu, H 2024, Estimating forest aboveground biomass using a combination of geographical random forest and empirical Bayesian kriging models. Remote Sensing, 16(11): 1859.

Yadav, BK & Nandy, S 2015, Mapping aboveground woody biomass using forest inventory, remote sensing and geostatistical techniques. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 187: 1-12.

Zhao, Z, Feng, Z, Liu, J & Wang, Y 2022, Development and testing of a new UWB positioning measurement tool to assist in forest surveys. Sustainability, 14(24): 17042.